Comets and life 2

Updating Comets and Magic Universe

Did comets spark life on Earth?

Part 2: Cosmic carbon compounds

An earlier post, Part 1 under this heading, commented enthusiastically but briefly on a French team’s find of extraterrestrial dust grains rich in carbon in the snow of Antarctica.

I promised more to come, and here it begins. Part 2 deals with cosmic carbon compounds. Later, Part 3 will reconsider the initiation of biochemical action, and Part 4 will look at suggestions of natural life footloose in space.

There were far more comets around when the Solar System was young, in the “heavy bombardment” phase of Earth history lasting until 3.8 billion years ago. Water is abundant in interstellar space and available to build the icy nuclei of comets. Comets may have delivered most of the Earth’s surface water, essential for life.

Carbon compounds are the other main ingredient for life. Comets’ tails consist mainly of small dust grains released from the nuclei, including grains laden with carbon compounds that may have contributed to the origin of life on the Earth. Here’s a general impression of important “prebiotic” molecules made in the vicinity of dying stars and newborn stars and available for incorporation into comets.

PAHs, polyaromatic hydrocarbons observable in interstellar space, could be ancestral to the aromatic compounds that have the very smell of life. Illustration from Pascale Ehrenfreund & Steven Charnley, 2000 – see reference. Graphic art: ©2000 R. Ruiterkamp

In Magic Universe, my story about “Molecules in space: exotic chemistry among the stars” has this sub-section:

Carbon lords of the jungle

The hunters extended their quest for molecules in cosmic space by using forms of invisible light coming from the Galaxy, that are mainly detectable only with aircraft, balloons, rockets or satellites. Interstellar hydrogen molecules, as opposed to solo atoms, first showed up in 1970 in an ultraviolet rocket-borne telescope. And in 1984, after using ground-based and airborne infrared telescopes to inspect some brightly lit dust clouds near stars, Alain Léger and Jean-Loup Puget at the Institut d’Astrophysique Spatiale in France reported possible signatures of very large exotic molecules, called polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, or PAHs for short.

These are molecules with perhaps 20 to 90 atoms of hydrogen and carbon, in which the carbon atoms are arranged in interlocking, polycyclic rings. Aromatic is a chemist’s term for molecules containing carbon rings in which the atoms pass electrons around like a loving cup. On the Earth, aromatic compounds smell of life, being ubiquitous among the key ingredients of living organisms, from the genes to the light-absorbing pigments of plants and eyes. In interstellar space, PAHs are chemically robust, and survive well.

For more than ten years after we predicted that PAHs should be ubiquitous, they seemed to be nothing more than a curious idea, inferred from the spectra of very few objects,’ Léger said. ‘But when the Infrared Space Observatory began operations in 1996 it immediately saw strong emissions in many different places in the sky, at exactly the wavelengths to be expected from PAHs. That was a happy confirmation of our prediction.’

In clouds around dying stars and newborn stars, or scattered far and wide in interstellar space, the Infrared Space Observatory, a European satellite (1995-98), discovered huge quantities of PAHs, signalled by intense emissions at a series of infrared wavelengths from 3 to 15 microns. The PAHs were detectable in other galaxies too. These lords of the cosmic molecular jungle may account for several per cent of all the free-range carbon in the Universe.

Doubters would at first speak only of ‘unidentified bands’ in the infrared spectrum. They complained that no one had detected benzene in interstellar space. Benzene is the basic aromatic ring, with just six carbon atoms. Without any sign of that, why believe in the PAHs? The objection disappeared when Spanish and Dutch astronomers re-examined observations of a dying star, and found the benzene signature. Chemists looked again at the carbon-rich material found in some in meteorites, and they discovered tangible PAHs delivered to the Earth from space.

Experimental chemists were inspired by astronomy to make novel materials. Most famous are the buckyballs, where 60 or 70 carbon atoms make football-like molecules from interlocking rings. Ironically, these had a huge impact on terrestrial chemistry and engineering research, before their identification in interstellar space — which early in the 21st Century remained at best ambiguous. But buckyballs were found in meteorites, so their extraterrestrial existence was not in doubt.

Best known for leading the Astrobiology Laboratory at the Leiden Institute of Chemistry, Pascale Ehrenfreund is currently Research Professor of Space Policy at George Washington University. Photo: Elliott School of International Affairs.

For updating Magic Universe, I find I did not err in betting heavily on the magic of PAHs. They have certainly thrived as a subject for investigation and now more details can be added. For a witness, here’s Pascale Ehrenfreund, whose diagram I use at the start of this post, in an interview about PAHs with Astrobiology Magazine:

We suggest the aromatic material can be used as a container, as a metabolic unit, and as a genetic information carrier. We think that aromatic material can be used for all three requirements for life. … You can’t have one compound to assemble material, and then add something else later on to do another function. They have to be combined from the beginning — life needs to have an identity, it needs energy, and it needs to be able to reproduce and evolve. That’s why PAHs are potentially so powerful, because with these aromatic compounds you can fulfil all three functions at the same time.

That triple function of the PAHs is well worth noting as an update.


P. Ehrenfreund & S.B. Charnley, “Organic Molecules in the Interstellar Medium, Comets and Meteorites: A Voyage from Dark Clouds to the Early Earth”, Annual Review of Astronomy & Astrophysics, Vol. 38, pp. 427-83, 2000

Ehrenfreund interview in Astrobiology Magazine


5 Responses to Comets and life 2

  1. Richard111 says:

    The origins of life and now more fascinating insights to the chemistry of life. Thank you for this posting.

    I’ve often wondered about the creation of the moon, (mars size objects not in stable orbits?) and why the solar system orbits the Milky Way galaxy with a wave like motion, rising above the galactic plane and descending below, over a 30 million year or so period.

    At about the time of the first appearance of life on earth the planet was rotating quite a bit more rapidly and the moon was very close. There must have been impressive tides sloshing about with not much in the way of continents with mountains to slow them down. A bit like a large chemical shaker you see in lab pictures, and all of this being vigorously stirred by a barrage of comets.

    Maybe this web page has a valid explanation. Interesting anyway.
    We’re From Sagittarius Dwarf Galaxy

  2. rms says:

    Thanks for a terrific article.

    (I find your fonts hard to read. Bold black sans serif is hard to read (compared to black with serifs). And, with my eyesight, the red fonts also hard. Can I get you to consider changing your fonts?)

    • calderup says:

      Thanks, Rob. After just a month I’m still learning and I’ll think over what you say about fonts and colours.

  3. rms says:

    today’s posting much better. lack of bold is much easier on my eyes … now put some thought on the use of red. appreciate your time.

  4. […] Comets and life 2 […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: